Opinion

The ₹1,500 Lie: How Fake ‘Factory Outlets’ and Paid Reels Are Flooding Kashmir with Counterfeit Brands

Ready
The ₹1,500 Lie: How Fake ‘Factory Outlets’ and Paid Reels Are Flooding Kashmir with Counterfeit Brands

Dr. Siddhartha Ghosh & Ammar Mehdi


Srinagar November 16 (KNS): Take a stroll through the markets of Srinagar, Anantnag, or Baramulla. You will see many vendors advertising the same products you find scrolling through local social media. You will see sneakers selling for prices anywhere from ?8,000- ?15,000 in authorized showrooms, and which seldom go on sale for less than ?8,000. You will see vendors selling these for ?1,500. Next to them, you will see heavy winter jackets by well-known brands such as The North Face, Columbia, and Patagonia selling for ?1,500 to ?2,000, when the real jackets sell for ?15,000 to ?25,000. Deception like this has spread throughout the Valley and has turned high end winter wear and global brands of footwear into bargain finds.

The phrases “factory outlet stock” and “export surplus” are among the many used by shopkeepers to try to explain why they are selling the products for such low prices. Some also use the phrase “customs seized lots” to explain why they are selling such products. But on any honest appraisal, these are all implausible reasons and give customers a false sense of security.

The global economics of the apparel industry tell a different story. Companies like Skechers and Columbia and The North Face destroy or recycle products that they deem defective in order to protect their brand from being sold in gray markets. Factory seconds are also seldom sold outside company run outlets. Discounts rarely go beyond 40-50%. So a jacket or a pair of shoes is never sold for a tenth of the original price.

What is sold in Kashmir, however, is not seconds. Products sold in Kashmir are manufactured by a counterfeiting network based throughout India and operating from different cities. Unbranded shoes and jackets are mass produced from inexpensive synthetic foam and polyester wadding in illegal workshops and have fake woven labels and embossed logos, hang tags and even QR codes that take buyers' phones to clone verification websites.

Local wholesalers purchase these "master copies" in bulk for 400-700 rupees and sell them in Kashmir for 1500-2500 rupees, and sometimes even lower. If traders labelled these goods as "first copies" or "replicas," budget-conscious customers at least would have understood what they were paying for. Traders also would have maintained a sense of commercial honesty. However, traders who charge a premium of 200-300 percent by deceiving customers and claiming these fakes are surplus from the original brand.
This shadow market recently has been rapidly growing due to hyperlocal promotion on Facebook Reels and Instagram. Dozens of micro-influencers and local vloggers, charging 1500-2000 rupees per video, or taking free shoes/jackets to promote a store, have been flooding the market. Thousands of customers, who follow these micro-influencers, are told that everything on the shelves is "100 percent original" and are pressurized to buy, as the stock is "limited."

Trade defenders say it provides employment opportunities for local youth as shop assistants and content creators.Click Here To Follow Our WhatsApp ChannelBut the thing to ponder is that creating jobs through deceitful means is exploitative. It causes the greatest harm to legit businesses. In Srinagar, legal retailers such as authorised franchise outlets and multi-brand shops pay a heavy price in the form of high rental, GST and brand royalty and lose customers to counterfeits. Customers prefer buying fakes even at twice the price.

Meanwhile, many content creators fail to realise that they could be incriminating themselves. Endorsers of fake goods can be held liable under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, for promoting misleading advertisements. For endorsing a product, one has to perform due diligence by confirming that the seller is the authorised distributor. A person endorsing a fake as original is liable under the Act, and has to bear the consequences. Influencers promoting fakes can even face a criminal case if the brand owner chooses to pursue the matter.

Equally worrying is the complete lack of accountability by the institutions mandated to police the market. As per the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, selling counterfeit goods under a registered trade name is a cognizable offense and provides for a prison term of up to three years. However, the local police will not act in the absence of a formal complaint and a technical verification by the brand’s legal team. The brands, in turn, depend on third-party anti-counterfeiting agencies. The emphasis of these agencies is on the large manufacturing hubs in the major cities and smaller markets like Kashmir are generally neglected.

An observation by the Jammu and Kashmir Legal Metrology Department, which enforces the Packaged Commodities Rules, accepts that it suffers from a severe shortage of staff. According to the Department, traders who say they should also be allowed to sell packaged commodities without mandatory MRP tags (Maximum Retail Price) say that there is a glaring double standard in the application of rules. They point out that street vendors are regularly penalized by the Department for minor infractions; however, big, multiplex-style "factory outlets" openly operate without issuing proper GST invoices.

In the absence of a detailed GST bill with a clear brand name and article code, consumers do not have the right to legal recourse if they purchase a product that causes them injury or distress. For example, foot pain because the midsole of the shoe not having adequate cushioning, or a jacket that does not keep out the cold during a Kashmiri winter.

Until law enforcement agencies work to enforce rules and regulations similarly against other businesses, and until global brands stop turning a blind eye to unlawful practices of local vendors, the general masses will keep on getting ripped off by such unethical business practices.(KNS)

The views in the article are author's own, by, Dr. Siddhartha Ghosh, Director, Red Lantern Analytica Foundation & Ammar Mehdi Communications Lead, ASPIRE. 

To Top